Caramelized Banana Cream Pie

(1 review)
Current Stock:
Adding to cart… The item has been added

A banana cream pie that beats all banana cream pies. We first caramelize our bananas in our house-made sauce. Then, we fold the succulent bananas into Grandma's Birdies famous vanilla cream filling. All of this deliciousness is hugged by an incredibly butter-filled biscoff graham crust.

How you can buy the Banana Cream Pie:

  • Large: It's big. Not a 9" skinny pie you find in grocery stores or other bakeries.(learn more)
  • Quads - 4 Personal: Four, 4.25 inch personal pies. Bigger than a slice, perfect for you!
  • Bites: By special order only. Email or call 208-457-7004.

Gluten Free Option* (pre order, 48 hours in advance):

This is made with a gluten free vanilla cookie crust.

  • Large
  • Quad Box: Four, 4.25 inch personal pies.

*Gluten Free obscene astericks statement - like most commercial kitchens, our kitchen is not a 100% gluten free.  However, we do take precaution and do our absolute best to make these pies without gluten, but there is a possibility for cross-contamination. 


  • 4
    It tasted phenomenal

    Posted by Nichole Reed on 14th Nov 2020

    The pie was fantastic, the perfect banana/custard/whipped cream ratio. Not overly sweet, and not so heavy you regret your post dinner treat. However, we all found the crust to be a bit disappointing. It was non existent in comparison to the filing, it doesn’t make this a dealbreaker for future purchase, but it was a letdown to not have a good ratio of crust to balance out the flavors of the pie.