Key Lime Pie

(5 reviews)
Current Stock:
Adding to cart… The item has been added

Key lime pie, Birdie style. Hand-squeezed key limes, toasted coconut flakes magically placed in all the right parts situated atop a mouth-watering, proprietary graham crust.

How you can buy the Key Lime Pie:

  • Large: It's big. Not a 9" skinny pie you find in grocery stores or other bakeries.(learn more)
  • Personal: We felt a slice just wasn't enough. (learn more)
  • Quads: When you feel like sharing or can't pick just one personal pie flavor. (learn more)
  • Bites: Only by the dozen, these cuties will take over the cookie. (learn more)

Gluten Free Key Lime Pie Option* (pre order, 48 hours in advance):

This is made with a gluten free, buttery vanilla cookie crust with our signature key lime filling. You'll LOVE this gluten free key lime pie!

  • Large: see above
  • Quads: see above

Bites & Quads Orders: You cannot order bites or quads on this page, please use the Bites or Quads menu item to find this pie in those categories.

*Gluten Free obscene astericks statement - like most commercial kitchens, our kitchen is not a 100% gluten free.  However, we do take precaution and do our absolute best to make these pies without gluten, but there is a possibility for cross-contamination. 


  • 5
    Best Pie Around

    Posted by Kelly Legg on 19th Jun 2021

    This is probably the best pie in town. Also the gluten free is amazing!

  • 5
    Amazing pie!

    Posted by Kelly Legg on 27th Feb 2021

    We loved the key lime pie! Not too sweet not too tart

  • 5
    Key Lime Pie

    Posted by Karen Cook on 9th Feb 2021

    So delicious!

  • 5
    Key Lime Pie

    Posted by Verna Blackhurst on 25th Jan 2021

    This pie was delicious. We ordered for my husband's birthday and it was a hit.

  • 5
    THE. BEST!

    Posted by Sonya Greenhalgh on 14th Feb 2020

    Key Lime is our favorite flavor so we have had many different key lime pies. Birdie's pie is hands down the best!! So creamy and smooth. The coconut is a great touch!